{ "$schema": "https://iarpg.com/country-context-audit-record.schema.json", "record_type": "iarpg-country-context-evidence-audit", "schema_version": "1.0", "release": "IARPG-OPS-2", "version": "2.0.23-wip", "audit_id": "country-context-audit-kiribati-2026-07-23", "status": "reviewed-with-limitations", "review_state": "model-generated-source-audit", "truth_boundary": "A claim-level, model-generated public-source audit of a preserved 2.0.22 draft proposal. It records evidence support, qualification, correction, and unanswered review questions. It is not independent human review, locally informed consultation, consent, exhaustive factual truth, legal determination, public-opinion measurement, geopolitical-neutrality certification, or approval for publication.", "created_utc": "2026-07-23T10:53:59Z", "updated_utc": "2026-07-23T10:53:59Z", "audit_cutoff": { "date": "2026-07-23", "exact_utc": "2026-07-23T10:53:59Z", "scope": "Public sources accessible by the model up to this exact UTC time; later changes are outside the audit." }, "country": { "name": "Kiribati", "slug": "kiribati", "region": "Oceania", "principal_source_environment": "English and Gilbertese/Kiribati" }, "original_proposal": { "proposal_id": "country-context-kiribati-2026-07-22", "version": "2.0.22-wip", "status": "draft", "record_url": "/country-context/proposals/kiribati.json", "public_url": "/country-context/drafts/kiribati", "sha256": "c3cc640f59ab2cfa8fa3368b1ae04abc0ce9860d2b1532ea307ab3246e710f95", "source_register_sha256": "1edfce33b6924cda4258738ba9cab33047deaeeec3b662e7a20b1f279c29e06f", "preservation_rule": "Immutable review input; not silently rewritten by this audit." }, "archival_orientation": { "source_publication": "Preserved 2025 World Context dataset", "source_record": "/world-context/entities/kiribati.json", "boundary": "Archival orientation only. No archival field is promoted to a current claim without renewed dated evidence." }, "separation_of_duties": { "deterministic_repository_checks": { "performed_by": "local deterministic scripts", "state": "performed", "scope": "Schema validity, path integrity, stable identifiers, counts, six-lens coverage, reciprocal links, manifest mappings, route availability, equal review burden, and prohibited-content checks.", "does_not_establish": "Factual truth, legal validity, source interpretation, human comprehension, local acceptance, or publication approval." }, "source_verification_checks": { "performed_by": "model-generated public-source audit", "state": "performed-with-limitations", "scope": "Re-opened or newly collected public sources current to the exact audit cutoff; recorded support, qualification, correction, disagreement search, source language, scope, and confidence claim by claim.", "does_not_establish": "Independent human review, exhaustive source discovery, consultation, consent, geopolitical neutrality, or locally informed acceptance." }, "independent_human_judgment": { "performed_by": null, "state": "not-performed", "scope": "Independent evaluation of materiality, legal interpretation, evidentiary sufficiency, wording neutrality, and publication fitness.", "required_evidence": "Named reviewer, qualifications or relevant experience, date, methods, conflicts, claim-level decisions, and attributable review record." }, "locally_informed_review": { "performed_by": null, "state": "not-performed", "scope": "Review by people with relevant local, linguistic, institutional, professional, or affected-community knowledge, with consent and publication scope recorded.", "required_evidence": "Attributable or consented anonymous reviewer record, language competence, relationship to the jurisdiction or affected institution/community, conflicts, claim-level responses, and permission boundaries." } }, "claim_audits": [ { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-01", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-01", "lens_id": "authority", "lens_title": "Formal and practical authority, implementation, oversight, remedy, and legitimacy", "original_statement": "The Office of Te Beretitenti identifies Taneti Maamau as President of Kiribati at the research cutoff.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-01", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-01.json", "disposition": "corroborated", "revised_statement": null, "change_summary": "Renewed public-source access continued to support the bounded original statement at the audit cutoff; no material contradiction or supersession was located in this pass.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-01", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-01.json", "new_evidence_relation": "renewed-corroboration", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The original source or a current authoritative route remained available and supported the claim within its stated institutional, geographic, and temporal scope.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "An independent reviewer should re-open the cited source, test the statement against any later correction or superseding instrument, and verify that no broader inference has been added beyond the source scope." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-01: Is the renewed source support sufficient for the exact bounded wording, and is any legally or politically material qualification missing?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-01 match locally used institutional and public terminology for current institutions; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-bounded-wording", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-02", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-02", "lens_id": "authority", "lens_title": "Formal and practical authority, implementation, oversight, remedy, and legitimacy", "original_statement": "Parliament identifies Willie Tokataake as Speaker, elected on 13 September 2024, and describes a chamber of 44 elected members plus a Banaban representative.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-02", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-02.json", "disposition": "corroborated", "revised_statement": null, "change_summary": "Renewed public-source access continued to support the bounded original statement at the audit cutoff; no material contradiction or supersession was located in this pass.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-02", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-02.json", "new_evidence_relation": "renewed-corroboration", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The original source or a current authoritative route remained available and supported the claim within its stated institutional, geographic, and temporal scope.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "An independent reviewer should re-open the cited source, test the statement against any later correction or superseding instrument, and verify that no broader inference has been added beyond the source scope." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-02: Is the renewed source support sufficient for the exact bounded wording, and is any legally or politically material qualification missing?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-02 match locally used institutional and public terminology for practical authority; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-bounded-wording", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-03", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-03", "lens_id": "coalitions", "lens_title": "Domestic coalitions, institutional disagreement, continuity, and policy change", "original_statement": "The Presidency's history page records Taneti Maamau's current term from 2025 to date, following earlier terms, documenting continuity in the executive office without implying institutional unanimity.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-03", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-03.json", "disposition": "corroborated-with-qualification", "revised_statement": "The Presidency's history page labels Taneti Maamau's current period as '2025 - To date' and lists earlier terms. Because the parliamentary and presidential election cycle began in 2024, the page's year label should be treated as an official-site periodization that awaits reconciliation with the formal election, gazette, or inauguration record.", "change_summary": "Retain what the official history page says without silently converting its year label into an independently verified term start.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-03", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-03.json", "new_evidence_relation": "qualification", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The claim accurately reported the page, but the timeline label is not self-explanatory and may not equal the election or inauguration date.", "confidence": "moderate", "resolution_test": "Locate the official presidential election result, gazette, oath or inauguration record, constitutional term calculation, and any corrected Presidency timeline; document the legally effective date separately from webpage periodization." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-03: Does the qualification accurately capture the source limitation without understating or overstating the underlying institution, disagreement, or implementation gap?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-03 match locally used institutional and public terminology for current institutions; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-with-qualification", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-04", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-04", "lens_id": "coalitions", "lens_title": "Domestic coalitions, institutional disagreement, continuity, and policy change", "original_statement": "Parliament publishes an individually addressable roster of current members, enabling coalition and institutional-disagreement research without inferring positions from island, language, or demographic identity.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-04", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-04.json", "disposition": "corroborated", "revised_statement": null, "change_summary": "Renewed public-source access continued to support the bounded original statement at the audit cutoff; no material contradiction or supersession was located in this pass.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-04", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-04.json", "new_evidence_relation": "renewed-corroboration", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The original source or a current authoritative route remained available and supported the claim within its stated institutional, geographic, and temporal scope.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "An independent reviewer should re-open the cited source, test the statement against any later correction or superseding instrument, and verify that no broader inference has been added beyond the source scope." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-04: Is the renewed source support sufficient for the exact bounded wording, and is any legally or politically material qualification missing?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-04 match locally used institutional and public terminology for source disagreements; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-bounded-wording", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-05", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-05", "lens_id": "regional-agency", "lens_title": "Regional organizations, overlapping memberships, and issue-specific agency", "original_statement": "The Commonwealth Secretariat lists Kiribati as a member and describes country-specific support areas.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-05", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-05.json", "disposition": "corroborated", "revised_statement": null, "change_summary": "Renewed public-source access continued to support the bounded original statement at the audit cutoff; no material contradiction or supersession was located in this pass.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-05", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-05.json", "new_evidence_relation": "renewed-corroboration", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The original source or a current authoritative route remained available and supported the claim within its stated institutional, geographic, and temporal scope.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "An independent reviewer should re-open the cited source, test the statement against any later correction or superseding instrument, and verify that no broader inference has been added beyond the source scope." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-05: Is the renewed source support sufficient for the exact bounded wording, and is any legally or politically material qualification missing?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-05 match locally used institutional and public terminology for alliances and issue specific relationships; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-bounded-wording", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-06", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-06", "lens_id": "regional-agency", "lens_title": "Regional organizations, overlapping memberships, and issue-specific agency", "original_statement": "The Pacific Community maintains a Kiribati country stream with government, technical, and community cooperation records, showing issue-specific participation rather than a unitary alignment.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-06", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-06.json", "disposition": "corroborated", "revised_statement": null, "change_summary": "Renewed public-source access continued to support the bounded original statement at the audit cutoff; no material contradiction or supersession was located in this pass.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-06", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-06.json", "new_evidence_relation": "renewed-corroboration", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The original source or a current authoritative route remained available and supported the claim within its stated institutional, geographic, and temporal scope.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "An independent reviewer should re-open the cited source, test the statement against any later correction or superseding instrument, and verify that no broader inference has been added beyond the source scope." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-06: Is the renewed source support sufficient for the exact bounded wording, and is any legally or politically material qualification missing?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-06 match locally used institutional and public terminology for alliances and issue specific relationships; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-bounded-wording", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-07", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-07", "lens_id": "dependencies", "lens_title": "Strategic dependencies, resilience, redundancy, substitutability, and affected communities", "original_statement": "The National Statistics Office publishes current population, trade, government-finance, survey, and community reports that provide official baselines while retaining known coverage and methodology limits.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-07", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-07.json", "disposition": "corroborated", "revised_statement": null, "change_summary": "Renewed public-source access continued to support the bounded original statement at the audit cutoff; no material contradiction or supersession was located in this pass.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-07", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-07.json", "new_evidence_relation": "renewed-corroboration", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The original source or a current authoritative route remained available and supported the claim within its stated institutional, geographic, and temporal scope.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "An independent reviewer should re-open the cited source, test the statement against any later correction or superseding instrument, and verify that no broader inference has been added beyond the source scope." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-07: Is the renewed source support sufficient for the exact bounded wording, and is any legally or politically material qualification missing?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-07 match locally used institutional and public terminology for economy and infrastructure; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-bounded-wording", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-08", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-08", "lens_id": "dependencies", "lens_title": "Strategic dependencies, resilience, redundancy, substitutability, and affected communities", "original_statement": "Pacific Community material for Kiribati identifies climate-related pressures on coastal and oceanic fisheries, reefs, livestock, and crop production; the proposal treats these as domain-specific evidence questions rather than permanent national traits.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-08", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-08.json", "disposition": "corroborated-with-qualification", "revised_statement": "Pacific Community material identifies observed or projected climate-related pressures relevant to Kiribati's fisheries, reefs, livestock, and crop production. These are domain- and source-bounded risk observations, not permanent national traits, uniform island conditions, or proof of a single causal outcome.", "change_summary": "Clarify observed-versus-projected evidence and block typecasting or uniform-island inference.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-08", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-08.json", "new_evidence_relation": "qualification", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "Regional technical material supports the domains, while temporal, island-level, and methodological differences require qualification.", "confidence": "moderate", "resolution_test": "Separate observed measurements from model projections; record island, species, period, method, uncertainty, local knowledge, distributional effects, and adaptation or recovery evidence for each downstream claim." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-08: Does the qualification accurately capture the source limitation without understating or overstating the underlying institution, disagreement, or implementation gap?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-08 match locally used institutional and public terminology for economy and infrastructure; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-with-qualification", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-09", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-09", "lens_id": "evidence-oversight", "lens_title": "Evidence reliability, credibility, confidence, disagreement, correction, and oversight", "original_statement": "The Kiribati Audit Office states that reports tabled in Parliament are available for public viewing and organizes financial, state-owned-enterprise, local-government, project, and performance-audit categories.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-09", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-09.json", "disposition": "corroborated", "revised_statement": null, "change_summary": "Renewed public-source access continued to support the bounded original statement at the audit cutoff; no material contradiction or supersession was located in this pass.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-09", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-09.json", "new_evidence_relation": "renewed-corroboration", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The original source or a current authoritative route remained available and supported the claim within its stated institutional, geographic, and temporal scope.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "An independent reviewer should re-open the cited source, test the statement against any later correction or superseding instrument, and verify that no broader inference has been added beyond the source scope." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-09: Is the renewed source support sufficient for the exact bounded wording, and is any legally or politically material qualification missing?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-09 match locally used institutional and public terminology for oversight and remedy; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-bounded-wording", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-10", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-10", "lens_id": "evidence-oversight", "lens_title": "Evidence reliability, credibility, confidence, disagreement, correction, and oversight", "original_statement": "The Public Service Office publishes integrity and corruption-reporting contacts, while this review did not establish a comprehensive national human-rights institution or equivalent remedy architecture from current primary sources.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-10", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-10.json", "disposition": "corroborated-with-qualification", "revised_statement": "The Public Service Office publishes integrity, corruption-reporting, whistleblowing, and customer-complaint channels. The audit did not locate current primary evidence establishing a comprehensive national human-rights institution; that is a bounded search result, not proof that no equivalent remedy body or mandate exists.", "change_summary": "Verify the available complaint routes and narrow the negative institutional claim to the limits of the search.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-10", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-10.json", "new_evidence_relation": "qualification", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "Positive evidence of PSO channels is direct. Absence claims require broader legal and local review than a public-web search can supply.", "confidence": "moderate", "resolution_test": "Review the Constitution, statutes, gazettes, justice and ombuds institutions, regional accreditation records, parliamentary materials, civil-society directories, and locally informed accounts for rights-remedy mandates and practical routes." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-10: Does the qualification accurately capture the source limitation without understating or overstating the underlying institution, disagreement, or implementation gap?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-10 match locally used institutional and public terminology for oversight and remedy; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-with-qualification", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-11", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-11", "lens_id": "crisis-recovery", "lens_title": "Crisis cascades, institutional response, unequal consequences, recovery, and uncertainty", "original_statement": "The National Statistics Office's current community reporting states that roughly one in four households reported disaster effects, an official survey result that remains subject to its definitions, sampling, and reference period.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-11", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-11.json", "disposition": "corroborated", "revised_statement": null, "change_summary": "Renewed public-source access continued to support the bounded original statement at the audit cutoff; no material contradiction or supersession was located in this pass.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-11", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-11.json", "new_evidence_relation": "renewed-corroboration", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The original source or a current authoritative route remained available and supported the claim within its stated institutional, geographic, and temporal scope.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "An independent reviewer should re-open the cited source, test the statement against any later correction or superseding instrument, and verify that no broader inference has been added beyond the source scope." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-11: Is the renewed source support sufficient for the exact bounded wording, and is any legally or politically material qualification missing?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-11 match locally used institutional and public terminology for environmental constraints; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": null, "publication_effect": "retain-bounded-wording", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" }, { "audit_claim_id": "audit-claim-kiribati-12", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-12", "lens_id": "crisis-recovery", "lens_title": "Crisis cascades, institutional response, unequal consequences, recovery, and uncertainty", "original_statement": "A Pacific Community climate-resilient building-code project reports stakeholder consultation and an affordability objective, showing that technical resilience choices include implementation and distributional questions.", "original_source_record_id": "source-kiribati-12", "original_source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-12.json", "disposition": "correction-required", "revised_statement": "SPC/NDC Hub material documents a 2024 consultation on climate-resilient building-code recommendations. The official Kiribati Building Code 2024 records a broader consultation process involving government, civil society, community, disability, youth, and industry stakeholders. Cost, affordability, compliance, and distributional outcomes remain implementation questions; this audit did not verify an affordability objective as a completed project outcome.", "change_summary": "Replace the unsupported affordability-objective wording with documented consultation and implementation boundaries.", "source_record_id": "audit-source-kiribati-12", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-evidence-audit-2.0.23/kiribati/audit-source-kiribati-12.json", "new_evidence_relation": "correction", "discrepancy_note": { "rationale": "The renewed sources clearly document consultation and a completed code. They do not support presenting affordability as a verified achieved objective, and consultation composition still requires locally informed review.", "confidence": "high", "resolution_test": "Review the final code, implementing law, cost analysis, enforcement guidance, financing or subsidy measures, contractor capacity, outer-island delivery, disability access, household affordability, and participant feedback with locally informed reviewers." }, "human_review_question": "For claim-kiribati-12: Does the proposed correction resolve the material error while preserving the original record and all relevant disagreement?", "locally_informed_review_prompt": "For a reviewer with relevant Kiribati knowledge: does the wording for claim-kiribati-12 match locally used institutional and public terminology for rights and affected communities; what implementation, access, disagreement, affected-community, island/region, language, or remedy evidence is missing; and may the response be quoted, summarized, or retained only privately?", "correction_record_id": "audit-correction-kiribati-12", "publication_effect": "correct-before-reuse", "human_review_state": "not-performed", "locally_informed_review_state": "not-performed" } ], "disposition_summary": { "corroborated": 8, "corroborated-with-qualification": 3, "correction-required": 1, "contradicted": 0, "superseded": 0, "unresolved": 0 }, "fictional_translation_review": [ { "translation_id": "translation-kiribati-institutional-crossroads", "source_claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-01", "claim-kiribati-02", "claim-kiribati-03", "claim-kiribati-04", "claim-kiribati-09", "claim-kiribati-10" ], "audit_state": "retained-as-bounded-fictional-design-prompt", "revision_required": false, "boundary": "No national, cultural, political, religious, ethnic, moral, loyalty, danger, recruitability, targetability, or permanent faction trait may be inferred. Any correction to a source claim must be applied before reuse." }, { "translation_id": "translation-kiribati-dependency-map", "source_claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-05", "claim-kiribati-06", "claim-kiribati-07", "claim-kiribati-08" ], "audit_state": "retained-as-bounded-fictional-design-prompt", "revision_required": false, "boundary": "No national, cultural, political, religious, ethnic, moral, loyalty, danger, recruitability, targetability, or permanent faction trait may be inferred. Any correction to a source claim must be applied before reuse." }, { "translation_id": "translation-kiribati-recovery-clock", "source_claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-09", "claim-kiribati-10", "claim-kiribati-11", "claim-kiribati-12" ], "audit_state": "retained-as-bounded-fictional-design-prompt", "revision_required": true, "boundary": "No national, cultural, political, religious, ethnic, moral, loyalty, danger, recruitability, targetability, or permanent faction trait may be inferred. Any correction to a source claim must be applied before reuse." } ], "locally_informed_review_packet": { "packet_id": "locally-informed-review-kiribati-2026-07-23", "record_url": "/country-context/audits/kiribati-review-packet.json", "responses_status": "not-collected" }, "correction_history": [ { "correction_id": "audit-correction-kiribati-12", "country": "Kiribati", "country_slug": "kiribati", "original_claim_id": "claim-kiribati-12", "recorded_utc": "2026-07-23T10:53:59Z", "status": "active-correction-before-reuse", "original_statement": "A Pacific Community climate-resilient building-code project reports stakeholder consultation and an affordability objective, showing that technical resilience choices include implementation and distributional questions.", "revised_statement": "SPC/NDC Hub material documents a 2024 consultation on climate-resilient building-code recommendations. The official Kiribati Building Code 2024 records a broader consultation process involving government, civil society, community, disability, youth, and industry stakeholders. Cost, affordability, compliance, and distributional outcomes remain implementation questions; this audit did not verify an affordability objective as a completed project outcome.", "rationale": "The renewed sources clearly document consultation and a completed code. They do not support presenting affordability as a verified achieved objective, and consultation composition still requires locally informed review.", "resolution_test": "Review the final code, implementing law, cost analysis, enforcement guidance, financing or subsidy measures, contractor capacity, outer-island delivery, disability access, household affordability, and participant feedback with locally informed reviewers.", "original_proposal_url": "/country-context/proposals/kiribati.json", "audit_record_url": "/country-context/audits/kiribati.json", "supersedes_record_id": null, "superseded_by_record_id": null, "human_approved": false, "locally_informed_review_completed": false } ], "fairness_review": { "profiles_compared": 5, "claim_count": 12, "claims_per_lens": 2, "contradiction_search_count": 12, "audit_source_record_count": 12, "human_review_question_count": 12, "locally_informed_prompt_count": 12, "human_review_response_count": 0, "locally_informed_response_count": 0, "common_blockers": [ "Independent human second pass has not been documented.", "Locally informed review has not been documented.", "Reviewer attribution, conflict-of-interest disclosure, consent, and publication scope remain blank.", "Affected-community representation is incomplete and cannot be inferred from public-source collection.", "Human publication approval has not been documented." ] }, "publication_gate": { "publishable": false, "maximum_state": "reviewed-with-limitations", "blockers": [ "Independent human second pass has not been documented.", "Locally informed review has not been documented.", "Reviewer attribution, conflict-of-interest disclosure, consent, and publication scope remain blank.", "Affected-community representation is incomplete and cannot be inferred from public-source collection.", "Human publication approval has not been documented." ], "warning": "A passing source-audit gate establishes reviewability and traceability only; it does not establish factual correctness, legal validity, local acceptance, political or geopolitical neutrality, or publication approval." } }