{ "$schema": "https://iarpg.com/country-context-proposal.schema.json", "record_type": "iarpg-country-context-proposal", "schema_version": "1.1", "release": "IARPG-OPS-2", "version": "2.0.22-wip", "proposal_id": "country-context-kiribati-2026-07-22", "status": "draft", "review_state": "draft-with-structural-checks", "truth_boundary": "Draft research proposal with an exact 2026-07-22 cutoff. Archival 2025 World Context material is orientation only; current observations are claim-level and dated; analyst assumptions are labeled and testable; fictional translations are bounded design prompts. This is not a live geopolitical feed, country ranking, legal determination, public-opinion survey, intelligence product, or publication-approved profile.", "created_utc": "2026-07-23T03:30:00Z", "updated_utc": "2026-07-23T03:30:00Z", "country": { "roadmap_name": "Kiribati", "region": "Oceania", "archival_entity_ids": [ "kiribati" ], "archival_source_entities": [ "Kiribati" ], "locally_used_name": "Kiribati", "endonym_notes": "The state name and I-Kiribati institutional terms are retained. English dominates the accessible official source set; that accessibility must not be mistaken for exhaustive I-Kiribati or outer-island representation.", "principal_source_environment": "English and I-Kiribati", "research_cutoff": "2026-07-22", "research_cutoff_utc": "2026-07-22T23:59:59Z", "profile_scope": "First balanced-batch draft; twelve current observations, two per World Systems lens, with no claim beyond the exact research cutoff." }, "archival_orientation": { "source_publication": "Preserved 2025 World Context dataset", "source_record": "/world-context/entities/kiribati.json", "source_entity_id": "kiribati", "source_code": "KI", "source_row_count": 127, "published_fact_count": 47, "available_lenses": [ "place", "people", "institutions", "economy", "infrastructure", "environment" ], "orientation_summary": { "population": 116545.0, "area_sq_km": 811.0, "capital": "Tarawa", "government_type": "presidential republic", "life_expectancy_years": 68.5, "urban_population_percent": 57.8, "internet_users_percent": 88.0, "electricity_access_percent": 94.4, "gdp_per_capita_usd": 3300.0, "gdp_per_capita_estimate_year": 2024, "landlocked": false }, "boundary": "Archival orientation only. No archival field is promoted to a current claim without renewed dated evidence." }, "sections": { "current_institutions": "The Presidency and Parliament identify current formal officeholders and the chamber structure. These records do not establish practical reach across every island or institution.", "practical_authority": "The combined presidential role and parliamentary structure are formal facts. Administrative capacity, island access, implementation, and public legitimacy require further locally informed evidence.", "oversight_and_remedy": "The Audit Office and Public Service Office expose audit and integrity channels. A comprehensive rights-remedy architecture was not established from the current primary source set and remains an explicit gap.", "rights_and_affected_communities": "Regional technical records include consultation and affordability objectives. They do not establish exhaustive outer-island, disability, gender, youth, or Banaban representation.", "economy_and_infrastructure": "Official statistics and regional technical context identify domains for dependency and resilience research. Financing, ownership, operation, substitution, and community effects remain separate.", "environmental_constraints": "Official survey reporting and building-code work document disaster effects and resilience planning. Model output, survey response, field observation, unequal effects, and recovery are not conflated.", "alliances_and_issue_specific_relationships": "Commonwealth membership and Pacific Community cooperation are issue-specific institutional contexts, not evidence of external control or a complete alignment.", "source_disagreements": "Official executive, parliamentary, audit, statistics, and regional programme sources have different scopes. The proposal exposes remedy and local-representation gaps rather than resolving them by inference.", "missing_evidence": "Missing evidence includes locally informed I-Kiribati review, outer-island and Banaban perspectives, project-level ownership and operation records, complaint outcomes, exact survey methodology review, and an independent second pass.", "uncertainty_statement": "Officeholder, chamber, and audit-publication claims are high confidence. Practical capacity, remedy completeness, island-level effects, affordability, and consultation representativeness remain moderate or unestablished." }, "current_claims": [ { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-01", "lens_id": "authority", "lens_title": "Formal and practical authority, implementation, oversight, remedy, and legitimacy", "section": "current_institutions", "statement": "The Office of Te Beretitenti identifies Taneti Maamau as President of Kiribati at the research cutoff.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Office of Te Beretitenti", "source_title": "President Taneti Maamau", "source_url": "https://www.president.gov.ki/", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-01", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-01.json", "source_type": "official executive biography", "scope": "Current head-of-state and head-of-government identity", "institutional_scope": "Office of Te Beretitenti", "geographic_scope": "national", "confidence": "high", "perspective_origin": "official-self-report", "language": "English", "original_language": "English with I-Kiribati institutional terminology", "translation_method": "No full translation required; I-Kiribati office title retained and English official page reviewed.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "direct", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports only the bounded institutional observation stated here." }, "notes": "The formal office combines head-of-state and head-of-government functions; this does not establish practical control over every institution or island." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-02", "lens_id": "authority", "lens_title": "Formal and practical authority, implementation, oversight, remedy, and legitimacy", "section": "practical_authority", "statement": "Parliament identifies Willie Tokataake as Speaker, elected on 13 September 2024, and describes a chamber of 44 elected members plus a Banaban representative.", "publication_date": "2024-09-13", "publication_date_note": "Speaker election date stated by Parliament; page publication date is not separately displayed.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Maneaba ni Maungatabu", "source_title": "Parliament of Kiribati home", "source_url": "https://www.parliament.gov.ki/", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-02", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-02.json", "source_type": "official parliamentary portal", "scope": "Current speaker and formal chamber composition", "institutional_scope": "Parliament", "geographic_scope": "national", "confidence": "high", "perspective_origin": "official-self-report", "language": "English", "original_language": "English and I-Kiribati", "translation_method": "Official English page reviewed; I-Kiribati institutional name retained.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "direct", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports only the bounded institutional observation stated here." }, "notes": "Formal chamber composition does not establish attendance, voting coalitions, or practical access across dispersed islands." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-03", "lens_id": "coalitions", "lens_title": "Domestic coalitions, institutional disagreement, continuity, and policy change", "section": "current_institutions", "statement": "The Presidency's history page records Taneti Maamau's current term from 2025 to date, following earlier terms, documenting continuity in the executive office without implying institutional unanimity.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Office of Te Beretitenti", "source_title": "History of the Presidency", "source_url": "https://www.president.gov.ki/government-of-kiribati/history-of-presidency.html", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-03", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-03.json", "source_type": "official executive history page", "scope": "Continuity of the current presidential term", "institutional_scope": "Office of Te Beretitenti", "geographic_scope": "national", "confidence": "high", "perspective_origin": "official-self-report", "language": "English", "original_language": "English", "translation_method": "No translation; official English page reviewed.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "direct", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports only the bounded institutional observation stated here." }, "notes": "Continuity in one office is not treated as a stability, legitimacy, or public-opinion score." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-04", "lens_id": "coalitions", "lens_title": "Domestic coalitions, institutional disagreement, continuity, and policy change", "section": "source_disagreements", "statement": "Parliament publishes an individually addressable roster of current members, enabling coalition and institutional-disagreement research without inferring positions from island, language, or demographic identity.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Maneaba ni Maungatabu", "source_title": "Current Members", "source_url": "https://www.parliament.gov.ki/index.php/members/current-members", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-04", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-04.json", "source_type": "official parliamentary roster", "scope": "Current member roster and visible affiliation fields", "institutional_scope": "Parliament", "geographic_scope": "national and constituency", "confidence": "high", "perspective_origin": "official-self-report", "language": "English", "original_language": "English and I-Kiribati", "translation_method": "Official page reviewed; names and labels retained; political positions require separate claim-level evidence.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "direct", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports only the bounded institutional observation stated here." }, "notes": "Roster information is not a public-opinion measure and is not used to infer permanent coalition behavior." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-05", "lens_id": "regional-agency", "lens_title": "Regional organizations, overlapping memberships, and issue-specific agency", "section": "alliances_and_issue_specific_relationships", "statement": "The Commonwealth Secretariat lists Kiribati as a member and describes country-specific support areas.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Commonwealth Secretariat", "source_title": "Kiribati", "source_url": "https://thecommonwealth.org/our-member-countries/kiribati", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-05", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-05.json", "source_type": "official international-organization country profile", "scope": "Formal Commonwealth membership and support relationship", "institutional_scope": "Commonwealth Secretariat", "geographic_scope": "international", "confidence": "high", "perspective_origin": "regional", "language": "English", "original_language": "English", "translation_method": "No translation; source reviewed in English.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "direct", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports only the bounded institutional observation stated here." }, "notes": "Membership and support are not treated as control, loyalty, or a complete account of Kiribati's regional agency." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-06", "lens_id": "regional-agency", "lens_title": "Regional organizations, overlapping memberships, and issue-specific agency", "section": "alliances_and_issue_specific_relationships", "statement": "The Pacific Community maintains a Kiribati country stream with government, technical, and community cooperation records, showing issue-specific participation rather than a unitary alignment.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Pacific Community", "source_title": "Kiribati country stream", "source_url": "https://www.spc.int/taxonomy/term/10", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-06", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-06.json", "source_type": "official regional technical-organization country stream", "scope": "Issue-specific regional technical cooperation", "institutional_scope": "Pacific Community", "geographic_scope": "regional and national", "confidence": "moderate", "perspective_origin": "regional", "language": "English", "original_language": "English", "translation_method": "No translation; source reviewed in English.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "partial", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports the presence of ongoing cooperation records; individual projects require separate review for finance, ownership, operation, and community effects." }, "notes": "Small-state agency is not reduced to vulnerability or dependence." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-07", "lens_id": "dependencies", "lens_title": "Strategic dependencies, resilience, redundancy, substitutability, and affected communities", "section": "economy_and_infrastructure", "statement": "The National Statistics Office publishes current population, trade, government-finance, survey, and community reports that provide official baselines while retaining known coverage and methodology limits.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Kiribati National Statistics Office", "source_title": "National Statistics Office", "source_url": "https://nso.gov.ki/", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-07", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-07.json", "source_type": "official national-statistics portal", "scope": "Availability of current official statistics and community reports", "institutional_scope": "National Statistics Office", "geographic_scope": "national and island-level", "confidence": "high", "perspective_origin": "official-self-report", "language": "English", "original_language": "English", "translation_method": "No translation; source reviewed in English.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "direct", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports only the bounded institutional observation stated here." }, "notes": "Official statistics are evidence products with definitions and coverage limits; they are not model-free observations of every community." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-08", "lens_id": "dependencies", "lens_title": "Strategic dependencies, resilience, redundancy, substitutability, and affected communities", "section": "economy_and_infrastructure", "statement": "Pacific Community material for Kiribati identifies climate-related pressures on coastal and oceanic fisheries, reefs, livestock, and crop production; the proposal treats these as domain-specific evidence questions rather than permanent national traits.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Pacific Community", "source_title": "Kiribati climate-change programme context", "source_url": "https://www.spc.int/cccpir/kiribati", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-08", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-08.json", "source_type": "regional technical-organization country context", "scope": "Reported sector-specific climate and resource context", "institutional_scope": "Pacific Community and Kiribati partners", "geographic_scope": "national and island communities", "confidence": "moderate", "perspective_origin": "regional", "language": "English", "original_language": "English", "translation_method": "No translation; source reviewed in English.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "contextual", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Provides regional technical context; current local conditions, substitutions, project arrangements, and affected-community priorities require direct island-level review." }, "notes": "Dependence, resilience, redundancy, and substitution are treated as domain- and time-specific." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-09", "lens_id": "evidence-oversight", "lens_title": "Evidence reliability, credibility, confidence, disagreement, correction, and oversight", "section": "oversight_and_remedy", "statement": "The Kiribati Audit Office states that reports tabled in Parliament are available for public viewing and organizes financial, state-owned-enterprise, local-government, project, and performance-audit categories.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Kiribati Audit Office", "source_title": "Special Audit Reports catalogue", "source_url": "https://kao.gov.ki/index.php/pages/reports/category/9-special-audit-reports", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-09", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-09.json", "source_type": "supreme audit institution report portal", "scope": "Audit-report availability and categories", "institutional_scope": "Kiribati Audit Office", "geographic_scope": "national and local government", "confidence": "high", "perspective_origin": "official-self-report", "language": "English", "original_language": "English", "translation_method": "No translation; source reviewed in English.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "direct", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports only the bounded institutional observation stated here." }, "notes": "Publication establishes an oversight channel, not complete audit coverage or implementation of every recommendation." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-10", "lens_id": "evidence-oversight", "lens_title": "Evidence reliability, credibility, confidence, disagreement, correction, and oversight", "section": "oversight_and_remedy", "statement": "The Public Service Office publishes integrity and corruption-reporting contacts, while this review did not establish a comprehensive national human-rights institution or equivalent remedy architecture from current primary sources.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "No publication date was displayed on the reviewed HTML page; null is retained rather than inventing a date.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Kiribati Public Service Office", "source_title": "Public Service Office", "source_url": "https://www.pso.gov.ki/", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-10", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-10.json", "source_type": "official public-service and integrity portal", "scope": "Visible integrity-reporting route and an explicitly retained remedy gap", "institutional_scope": "Public Service Office", "geographic_scope": "national", "confidence": "moderate", "perspective_origin": "local", "language": "English", "original_language": "English and I-Kiribati", "translation_method": "Official bilingual labels reviewed; legal scope of complaint mechanisms remains subject to locally informed review.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "partial", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports the visible integrity contacts; it does not establish a complete rights-remedy system or practical accessibility." }, "notes": "The missing rights-remedy evidence is exposed rather than filled by inference." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-11", "lens_id": "crisis-recovery", "lens_title": "Crisis cascades, institutional response, unequal consequences, recovery, and uncertainty", "section": "environmental_constraints", "statement": "The National Statistics Office's current community reporting states that roughly one in four households reported disaster effects, an official survey result that remains subject to its definitions, sampling, and reference period.", "publication_date": "2025-01-01", "publication_date_note": "Report year is displayed; 1 January is a machine-sort placeholder and is not claimed as the exact publication day.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Kiribati National Statistics Office", "source_title": "2025 community and household reports", "source_url": "https://nso.gov.ki/", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-11", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-11.json", "source_type": "official statistics publication summary", "scope": "Survey-reported household disaster effects", "institutional_scope": "National Statistics Office", "geographic_scope": "national and household", "confidence": "moderate", "perspective_origin": "official-self-report", "language": "English", "original_language": "English", "translation_method": "No translation; source reviewed in English.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "partial", "locator": "HTML homepage summary linking to 2025 community reports.", "scope_note": "Supports the summarized survey result only; exact questionnaire, sampling, island distribution, severity, and recovery require report-level review." }, "notes": "The claim is not a forecast and does not convert exposure into a stability or threat score." }, { "claim_id": "claim-kiribati-12", "lens_id": "crisis-recovery", "lens_title": "Crisis cascades, institutional response, unequal consequences, recovery, and uncertainty", "section": "rights_and_affected_communities", "statement": "A Pacific Community climate-resilient building-code project reports stakeholder consultation and an affordability objective, showing that technical resilience choices include implementation and distributional questions.", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_note": "The reviewed HTML page did not expose a dependable publication date; null is retained rather than inventing one.", "access_date": "2026-07-22", "source_identity": "Pacific Community", "source_title": "Kiribati climate-resilient building code", "source_url": "https://www.spc.int/kiribati-enhancing-climate-resilience-through-the-upgrading-of-its-national-building-codes", "source_record_id": "source-kiribati-12", "source_record_url": "/docs/source-files/current-country-proposals-2.0.22/kiribati/source-kiribati-12.json", "source_type": "regional technical-programme report", "scope": "Reported stakeholder consultation and affordability consideration", "institutional_scope": "Kiribati government, SPC, and stakeholders", "geographic_scope": "national and community", "confidence": "moderate", "perspective_origin": "affected-community", "language": "English", "original_language": "English", "translation_method": "No translation; source reviewed in English.", "review_state": "source-checked", "claim_support": { "support_type": "partial", "locator": "Named page and visible institutional record.", "scope_note": "Supports the reported consultation and design objective; it does not establish representativeness, adoption, enforcement, affordability in practice, or equal benefit." }, "notes": "Community participation and unequal consequences remain explicit review questions." } ], "analyst_assumptions": [ { "assumption_id": "assumption-kiribati-authority", "statement": "Formal institutional routes in Kiribati are likely to be uneven proxies for practical implementation across agencies and places.", "rationale": "The current source set documents mandates and officeholders more consistently than implementation outcomes.", "confidence": "moderate", "test_needed": "Compare current audit findings, administrative performance data, complaint outcomes, and locally informed accounts across at least two institutional or subnational settings." }, { "assumption_id": "assumption-kiribati-dependency", "statement": "The practical effect of a strategic dependency will vary by sector, ownership, operating arrangement, substitution options, and affected community.", "rationale": "Membership, finance, trade, or cooperation records do not alone establish control, resilience, or public effect.", "confidence": "high", "test_needed": "Build a project- or sector-specific record separating financing, ownership, operation, regulation, redundancy, substitutability, service outcomes, and community evidence." }, { "assumption_id": "assumption-kiribati-review", "statement": "Additional local-language and locally informed review could materially change emphasis, confidence, or missing-evidence findings.", "rationale": "The draft is source-rich but has no documented independent second pass or locally informed reviewer.", "confidence": "high", "test_needed": "Commission an independent second pass and a locally informed review, record disagreements at claim level, and update correction and supersession history without silently overwriting the first draft." } ], "fictional_gameplay_translations": [ { "translation_id": "translation-kiribati-institutional-crossroads", "concept": "Institutional crossroads", "design_use": "Create a fictional scenario inspired by the documented fact that Kiribati contains multiple formal decision, oversight, or remedy routes. Players must identify which fictional institution has authority, capacity, evidence, and remedy for the immediate problem.", "safeguards": "Use invented institutions, people, locations, and disputes. Do not convert current parties, officeholders, constitutional forms, or communities into permanent faction morality, competence, loyalty, or threat traits.", "source_claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-01", "claim-kiribati-02", "claim-kiribati-03", "claim-kiribati-04", "claim-kiribati-09", "claim-kiribati-10" ] }, { "translation_id": "translation-kiribati-dependency-map", "concept": "Dependency and substitution map", "design_use": "Build a fictional resource or service problem in which finance, ownership, operation, regulation, redundancy, and substitution are separate clues rather than one control meter.", "safeguards": "Keep all actors fictional, make cooperation domain-specific, show affected communities and alternatives, and never infer alignment from geography, trade, infrastructure finance, membership, or a single decision.", "source_claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-05", "claim-kiribati-06", "claim-kiribati-07", "claim-kiribati-08" ] }, { "translation_id": "translation-kiribati-recovery-clock", "concept": "Oversight and recovery clock", "design_use": "Model a fictional crisis as a conditional sequence of detection, institutional response, unequal effects, complaint or audit, correction, and recovery, with visible uncertainty at each stage.", "safeguards": "Do not reproduce real vulnerabilities, targets, operational procedures, or evasion methods. Do not treat source confidence as a severity score or a community as inherently vulnerable, dangerous, or recruitable.", "source_claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-09", "claim-kiribati-10", "claim-kiribati-11", "claim-kiribati-12" ] } ], "correction_history": [ { "correction_id": "correction-kiribati-first-draft", "recorded_date": "2026-07-22", "status": "first-draft", "description": "Initial claim-level draft created from the bounded source register. No prior proposal is silently overwritten.", "affected_claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-01", "claim-kiribati-02", "claim-kiribati-03", "claim-kiribati-04", "claim-kiribati-05", "claim-kiribati-06", "claim-kiribati-07", "claim-kiribati-08", "claim-kiribati-09", "claim-kiribati-10", "claim-kiribati-11", "claim-kiribati-12" ], "supersedes": [], "superseded_by": null } ], "supersession": { "supersedes_proposal_ids": [], "superseded_by": null, "note": "First proposal record for this jurisdiction in the current-country series. Later records must link here rather than replace it silently." }, "fairness_review": { "checked_utc": "2026-07-23T03:30:00Z", "profiles_compared": 5, "findings": [ { "finding_id": "fairness-kiribati-equal-claim-burden", "status": "pass-structural-only", "description": "Twelve current claims are present, with exactly two claims under each of the six lenses." }, { "finding_id": "fairness-kiribati-tone-boundary", "status": "pass-structural-only", "description": "No country score, permanent faction trait, threat label, loyalty inference, or regional-representativeness claim is present." }, { "finding_id": "fairness-kiribati-human-review", "status": "open", "description": "Locally informed review and an independent second pass remain undocumented." } ], "adjective_terms": [], "threat_terms": [], "evidence_summary": { "claim_count": 12, "claims_per_lens": { "authority": 2, "coalitions": 2, "crisis-recovery": 2, "dependencies": 2, "evidence-oversight": 2, "regional-agency": 2 }, "perspective_origins": { "affected-community": 1, "local": 1, "official-self-report": 7, "regional": 3 }, "principal_source_environment": "English and I-Kiribati", "source_record_count": 12, "review_state_ceiling": "claim-checked" } }, "publication_gate": { "publishable": false, "checked_utc": "2026-07-23T03:30:00Z", "blockers": [ "Independent second-pass review has not been completed.", "Locally informed review has not been documented.", "Current-source collection is bounded and not exhaustive.", "No human publication approval has been recorded." ], "warnings": [ "A structural validation pass establishes reviewability only; it does not prove factual correctness, legal validity, local acceptance, political neutrality, or publication approval.", "Officeholders, institutional roles, budgets, memberships, and public policies can change after the exact research cutoff." ] }, "extensions": { "batch_id": "balanced-current-country-batch-2026-07-22", "batch_selection_seed": "IARPG-OPS-2-2.0.22-wip-balanced-batch-1", "selection_digest": "1b8f69527fd7cd19af0f903d1dd4cc64ec7f3522268917d46ddaa142c13579c6", "selection_rationale_url": "/docs/report/current-country-proposals-balanced-batch-selection-and-comparative-fairness#neutral-selection-rationale", "small_state_in_batch": true, "world_systems_lenses": [ { "lens_id": "authority", "title": "Formal and practical authority, implementation, oversight, remedy, and legitimacy", "claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-01", "claim-kiribati-02" ] }, { "lens_id": "coalitions", "title": "Domestic coalitions, institutional disagreement, continuity, and policy change", "claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-03", "claim-kiribati-04" ] }, { "lens_id": "regional-agency", "title": "Regional organizations, overlapping memberships, and issue-specific agency", "claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-05", "claim-kiribati-06" ] }, { "lens_id": "dependencies", "title": "Strategic dependencies, resilience, redundancy, substitutability, and affected communities", "claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-07", "claim-kiribati-08" ] }, { "lens_id": "evidence-oversight", "title": "Evidence reliability, credibility, confidence, disagreement, correction, and oversight", "claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-09", "claim-kiribati-10" ] }, { "lens_id": "crisis-recovery", "title": "Crisis cascades, institutional response, unequal consequences, recovery, and uncertainty", "claim_ids": [ "claim-kiribati-11", "claim-kiribati-12" ] } ], "source_register_url": "/country-context/proposals/kiribati-source-register.json", "correction_register_url": "/country-context/proposals/correction-and-supersession-register.json", "canonical_report_url": "/docs/report/current-country-proposal-kiribati", "public_draft_url": "/country-context/drafts/kiribati", "automated_check_boundary": "Passing automated structure and source-presence checks establishes reviewability only. It does not establish human comprehension, exhaustive local representation, geopolitical neutrality, factual correctness, legal or scientific validity, publication approval, or live-site behavior." } }